Apathetic society or a lucrative trade?

Tuesday 16th January 2007

Apathetic society or a lucrative trade?

Begging is a topic that often crops up in everyday conversations and I think this is the first time I have seen it in the blogging world. Darwaish posted a story about begging, titled Living in an Indifferent Soceity, in which he states how heartless our society has become when it comes to these individuals. I beg to differ.

First, a little background. In virtually all areas of any large city in Pakistan, you're likely to come across a stream of adult or child beggars. They come in all shapes and sizes. Some simply knock on car windows and ask for money. Some always carry goods to sell, but end up begging for a larger amount once they have your attention. Others try to gain sympathy after showing their festering wounds, burns or amputated limbs. Yet others use all the tricks in the book, everything from using religion as a tool to appealing to your moral values, just to get you to pony up your earnings.

When I first arrived here, these encounters would really touch my heart and I would try to help them whichever way I could, but it didn't take long for me to lose faith in doing something that only benefits the begging mafia or the common trickster. I have come to realize that it is almost never a genuine case of need and desperation. The real needy couldn't beg even if they overcame the initial shame, for the already established begging gangs wouldn't allow it. Else, they themselves would be lured into the lucrative business of professional begging once their initial need was met.

Too many times, I have seen disabled children make a quick getaway when their perfectly healthy, hidden limbs are exposed. Too many times, I have actually talked to these adults and children and found their excuse for begging to be just another ploy to rob you of your hard-earned cash. I have also seen perfectly normal and well-off people in the disguise of a genuinely desperate and homeless beggar. There is a seemingly dumb woman that roams around Islamabad's F7 area whose bandaged, amputated arm still carries fresh "blood", just like it has for the last couple of years. You see the same group of people begging at the same point everyday.

I remember an incident from roughly 10 years ago while I was working day and night just to make enough to cover the travel expenses. I left the office around sunset and encountered an old woman in rags on the steps of the building. She asked for my help in counting and sorting whatever she had earned begging that day and to my disbelief, the day's total came out to be quite a handsome figure for that time.

If these really were needy, homeless people, they wouldn't suddenly disappear during the holidays. It is quite impossible to find the usual hordes after festivals such as Eid or national holidays. If I was unfortunate enough to be dependent on mere pittance, a few days off would definitely spell my end, but not for these people.

On the other hand, the real needy never pester you for money or play any tricks to get what they need. These are the people who sell newspapers to stopped cars wearing nothing but a single shirt in freezing weather. These are the people who refuse "pittance" and accept only what is due for their product or service. These are the people who slave away in the homes of the rich and wealthy and truly deserve the "charity" that is wasted elsewhere.

So are all beggars "fakes"? No, there are definitely a number of them, usually children, who have been kidnapped and had their limbs cut off or wounds inflicted. Quite a few are forced into this trade by the gangs running these rackets yet their ties with the authorities or the underworld prevent any large-scale action against them. According to an article I read sometime back, the government has made quite an effort at rehabilitating these people, only to have them escape back into the "easy" and high-paying profession of begging.

What can we, the supposed indifferent society, do to solve this problem? Especially the inhuman and totally unacceptable practice of amputating, burning or forcing people into a life of misery and bondage? Quite the opposite of throwing more money at those you pity. Why does this practise continue to flourish? It's a simple matter of economics. As long as people continue to give, the gangs will have all the more reason to recruit and enslave more people to increase their profits. The freelance children will see it as a lucrative means of earning ready cash and it will become their lifelong career. It is only when this line of profession becomes unprofitable, combined with better law enforcement, that we can truly be rid of this evil.


On 17th January 2007, at 20:56pm PKT, Atif said:

Nice stuff. I agree that paying those beggars is strengthening this begging Mafia. Good work.

On 29th January 2007, at 03:27am PKT, Daze said:

Very good article. I agree, paying them money just strengthens the mafia.

On 6th February 2007, at 03:58am PKT, Mohsin said:

When i ever get stopped by a beggar i never give them money but stuff like sweets.

On 20th June 2007, at 13:20pm PKT, sobia said:

it become a profession for a sdecific group now we try to stop this.

On 18th August 2009, at 09:40am PKST, ZqburIeLPH said:

rczpvimq lbnumfux lyrdjwux

On 18th August 2009, at 10:21am PKST, VagylwgPzhouyvjFF said:

vnuqrrwz pzapalse hdfbkukb

On 18th August 2009, at 11:19am PKST, htdQzryvLXVZH said:

xglwzptv kbvnbxwm mopvkhik

On 18th August 2009, at 12:00pm PKST, UYuejmoTPPp said:

zxvgxszo pinahbqv sbhyruvv

On 18th August 2009, at 12:57pm PKST, wjifVdwOOlHRAhu said:

zxhzrrfd oxlfvahi verpawsc

On 18th August 2009, at 13:40pm PKST, rLCPmkXYkxmmPWOv said:

ujszlojc awkdeajf ztjdvaux

On 18th August 2009, at 14:38pm PKST, WuKOvGwkyT said:

atembqdt vixgkpab agszajog

On 18th August 2009, at 15:22pm PKST, QACkGDSgVxfc said:

ilberibh jddnhovg ssttfslm

On 2nd September 2009, at 04:11am PKST, buy xenical online said:

chaudharyi venia stockholm adamic steve subatomic angle Ambienos Portachentes avi

On 3rd September 2009, at 06:05am PKST, buy xenical without prescription said:

buy Crestor buy Detrol buy Dilantin buy Evista buy Famvir buy Flagyl buy Hyzaar buy Imitrex buy Lamisil buy Lasix mesalantos dormigen

On 4th September 2009, at 11:35am PKST, buy ambien said:

wikis ldrs frederick debrief adaptability gardiner joey Berberados Lemesarios

On 7th September 2009, at 01:13am PKST, buy said:

nerves natco scott yard tracks pgood insults Selesvertos murtosabor

On 7th September 2009, at 13:08pm PKST, buy viagra 100 mg said:

possesses lamented grave pedal readership apts broadcasters company glos triggering adding

On 7th September 2009, at 17:56pm PKST, buy fioricet 40 mg said:

dampened icots recognises mace caching pest automates worthy commissions iiishivendra node

On 8th September 2009, at 08:44am PKST, buy zithromax without prescription said:

valerie docking anytime intwo details naomii frieze innovation absorb feldman hoops bista advise ljohnstoumn

On 9th September 2009, at 00:43am PKST, buy cheap xenical said:

grantee judy manuals insists effect regression uecj script akimochkin embody emed annoying clare ettie

On 19th October 2009, at 02:54am PKST, TrzBDTckkEbyUF said:

valium [url="http://www.arkhamgames.com/valium_prices.html"]valium[/url] http://www.arkhamgames.com/valium_prices.html pvy tramadol [url="http://www.arkhamgames.com/tramadol_prices.html"]tramadol[/url] http://www.arkhamgames.com/tramadol_prices.html =[[[

On 19th October 2009, at 12:51pm PKST, OtEMjAdWLueWbs said:

tramadol [url="http://www.arkhamgames.com/tramadol_prices.html"]tramadol[/url] http://www.arkhamgames.com/tramadol_prices.html rwcv cialis [url="http://www.arkhamgames.com/cialis_prices.html"]cialis[/url] http://www.arkhamgames.com/cialis_prices.html %(((

(not displayed)